Crywolf - Emerald

[outstandingbalance]

[chatting goes here]

Comments

[cerealpunner]

Shouldn't it be "ladies first"?

Tiger's Eye made me suspicious with their faulty logic of why they chose Emerald. Coral... Kit's reason felt contrived and then there's the fact that he starts the chain of who voted what without offering up Coral's vote first.

Basically it's little things but enough to make me think it's one of the two and not Peridot.

[outstandingbalance]

I noticed that with Coral—that they asked about votes without offering their own. Also interesting that they didn't vote in the first round at all, even though they have a lot of players.

Tiger's eye... I've seen the least with them. I'm talking to them in private. We'll see what they say.

Mostly, though, it's more that Peridot felt innocent to me. Jean hasn't been around, which I'm not sure about, but Peridot's mix up with the votes didn't feel like something that would happen if they were mice. They wouldn't have a reason to draw attention to themselves, and they would have had a plan together. They didn't.

So in the end, I'm aiming for Coral and Tiger's eye in the next poll. See how they react under pressure. Both of them have a lot of people playing, so there's a good chance someone will crack.

[cerealpunner]

That's one way to go about it. Definitely'll get someone sweating somewhere.

... though I'm leaning more toward Coral because of their experience compared to Tiger's Eye, if the knight with Iolite wasn't lying about that. Coral knows the game and have been around the block enough to know effective ways to play the game. If they have one newbie with everyone else they have on the team, they can easily cover for slipups.

[outstandingbalance]

I haven't talked to him yet—or with Iolite much. What did he say? That most of the Tiger's Eye players were newer teammates?

[cerealpunner]

Pretty much. Or at least weren't here to play in the last one.

[outstandingbalance]

Fair point, though neither were we.

That said, Coral's felt more defensive in private than Tiger's Eye.

[cerealpunner]

Yeah? Probably should have a talk with them myself...

[outstandingbalance]

That's your call, but I'd be interested in knowing your take on them if you do.

[outstandingbalance]

Are you sticking with Coral on this one?

[cerealpunner]

I'll have to talk it out some more. Why? Having doubts?

[outstandingbalance]

Just getting a gauge on who's on my side.

[cerealpunner]

Natasha, if you know me at all, you know I side with justice.

[it's a joke. mostly]

[outstandingbalance]

Reassuring.

[cerealpunner]

Always glad to help with that.

[cerealpunner]

Looks like people are questioning Amethyst calling Coral "defensive" when they've seemed pretty open so far. Any explanation on that?

[outstandingbalance]

I just opened my private post with Coral to everyone.

[cerealpunner]

... well, gotta say. I didn't think Emerald came across as suspicious for that. Good to know.

But as for them seeming defensive... no one likes talking about previous bad experiences in games.

[roomforhope]

Peridot seems like a team that'd be good at lying, but I don't feel like they're trying to lie this time.

[outstandingbalance]

I'm sure they're good at lying. Even if they're lying, it doesn't benefit them. Could be wrong, but for the time being... I'm taking them out of the equation.

[roomforhope]

It's a good plan, especially considering how suspicious other people are being.

[outstandingbalance]

You have some feelings on Coral and Tiger's Eye?

[roomforhope]

It just seems weird that you'd ask for other people's votes and not give your own, considering the circumstances.

[outstandingbalance]

It definitely is. Especially if you didn't vote in the first place.

[roomforhope]

Yeah, really. . . [ considers '-'! ]

Are you going to vote for Coral, then?

[outstandingbalance]

Probably. I was planning to put our vote down on them in about fifteen minutes or so.